⚽ The King vs The Goalscoring Machine - Two legends in their prime
Eric Cantona scored 18 goals with 16 non-penalty goals, achieving a goal rate of 0.53 goals per game (18 goals in 34 appearances). Alan Shearer had a remarkable 31 goals with 28 non-penalty goals, achieving a superior goal rate of 0.78 goals per game (31 goals in 40 appearances). Shearer clearly demonstrated superior goal threat and finishing ability, outscoring Cantona by 13 goals despite playing just 6 more matches.
Cantona contributed 12 assists, showcasing exceptional creativity with 0.35 assists per game. In contrast, Shearer had only 4 assists, equating to 0.10 assists per game. Cantona was clearly the more creative player, significantly impacting Manchester United's attacking play through his vision and passing ability, compensating for his lower goal output with superior playmaking.
Cantona contributed to 23% of Manchester United's goals (18 of 79) and 22% of assists (12 of 55). Shearer was absolutely pivotal for Blackburn, contributing 49% of team goals (31 of 63) but only 10% of assists (4 of 42). Shearer's higher percentage illustrates his crucial importance to Blackburn's title-winning campaign, making him the focal point of their attack in a way that Cantona wasn't for United's more balanced offensive approach.
Cantona played 2,987 minutes with a per-90 goal rate of 0.54 and assists of 0.36. Shearer logged 3,145 minutes, achieving a superior per-90 goal rate of 0.89 and assists of 0.11. Shearer demonstrated significantly better efficiency in goal scoring per 90 minutes, nearly doubling Cantona's goal rate, though Cantona's creative efficiency was three times higher.
Cantona received 2 yellow cards and 2 red cards, indicating a volatile discipline record that cost United in crucial moments. Shearer had 2 yellow cards but no red cards, showcasing superior reliability and availability for his team throughout the season. Shearer's better discipline record contributed significantly to his team's success and consistency.
Manchester United scored 79 goals total while Blackburn scored 63 goals. Cantona's contributions came from a stronger, more prolific attacking unit, while Shearer's numbers are more impressive given Blackburn's less potent overall attack. This context makes Shearer's 49% goal contribution even more remarkable, as he carried a greater offensive burden for his title-winning team.
In raw numbers, Shearer outperformed Cantona with 35 total goal contributions (31 goals + 4 assists) compared to Cantona's 30 (18 goals + 12 assists). While Cantona excelled in creativity, Shearer's superior goal-scoring ability, efficiency, and team impact marked him as the more statistically dominant player in this legendary 1993-94 season.
Want to compare your own player matchups? Use our AI-powered tool to get instant, data-driven analysis of any Premier League players across different seasons.
Compare Players