2004-05 Premier League Season

Frank Lampard vs Steven Gerrard

⚽ The ultimate midfield debate from Mourinho's first title season

🤖 AI Evaluation

Frank Lampard was definitively the better player in the 2004/2005 Premier League season, showcasing superior goal-scoring, creativity, and overall impact on his team's success.

In one of the most heated Premier League debates, our AI analysis of 2004-05 data delivers a controversial verdict: Lampard dominated Gerrard with 31 goal contributions vs 11, higher efficiency, and greater team impact in Chelsea's title-winning campaign.
Frank Lampard
Chelsea
Age
26
Position
Midfielder
Nationality
England
Appearances
38
Key Statistics
13
Goals
18
Assists
31
G+A
0.34
Goals/90
0.47
Assists/90
3,413
Minutes
Team Impact
18%
Team Goals
31%
Team Assists
0
Red Cards
Steven Gerrard
Liverpool
Age
24
Position
Midfielder
Nationality
England
Appearances
30
Key Statistics
7
Goals
4
Assists
11
G+A
0.26
Goals/90
0.15
Assists/90
2,463
Minutes
Team Impact
14%
Team Goals
10%
Team Assists
0
Red Cards

📊 The Complete Statistical Breakdown

⚽ Goal Threat & Finishing

Frank Lampard scored 13 goals with 10 non-penalty goals. His goal rate of 0.34 goals per 90 minutes showcases his finishing ability. Steven Gerrard, in contrast, netted 7 goals, all of which were non-penalty. His goal rate stands at 0.25 goals per 90 minutes. Verdict: Lampard clearly had the edge in goal-scoring prowess.

🎨 Creative Impact

Lampard provided 18 assists, contributing significantly to Chelsea's attacking play. His creativity is highlighted by his 0.47 assists per 90 minutes. Gerrard managed only 4 assists, translating to 0.15 assists per 90 minutes, indicating a less impactful creative role. Verdict: Lampard was the more creative player, significantly impacting his team's offensive output.

⚡ Team Dependency & Impact

Lampard contributed 18% of Chelsea's goals and 31% of their assists, making him a pivotal figure in their attack. Gerrard accounted for 14% of Liverpool's goals and a mere 10% of their assists, showcasing a lesser impact on his team's overall performance. Verdict: Lampard was undeniably more crucial to his team's offensive strategy.

⏱️ Minutes & Efficiency

Lampard played 3,413 minutes across 38 appearances, averaging 0.91 goals + assists per 90 minutes. Gerrard, with 2,463 minutes in 30 appearances, averaged 0.40 goals + assists per 90 minutes. Verdict: Lampard was not only more present but also more efficient in contributing to his team's scoring.

🟨 Discipline & Reliability

Lampard received 6 yellow cards but no reds, showing a level of discipline despite a high number of matches played. Gerrard had 3 yellow cards, also with no reds, but missed 8 matches due to fitness issues, impacting his availability. Verdict: Lampard's reliability in being available for selection gives him an advantage here.

🏆 Squad Context

Chelsea scored 71 goals and provided 58 assists, while Liverpool managed 49 goals and 42 assists. The attacking strength of Chelsea allowed Lampard to thrive. The disparity in team performance directly influenced their individual statistics, with Lampard benefiting from a stronger squad. Verdict: Lampard performed in a more potent attacking environment.

📈 Overall Statistical Dominance

In terms of raw numbers, Lampard outperformed Gerrard in goals, assists, and overall contributions to the team's success. His combined total of 31 goal contributions (goals + assists) dwarfs Gerrard's 11 contributions. Verdict: Lampard demonstrated superior overall statistical dominance.

Settle the Debate

Want to compare your own player matchups? Use our AI-powered tool to get instant, data-driven analysis of any Premier League players across different seasons.

Compare Players