⚽ The Norwegian Goal Machine vs Swedish Sharpshooter
Erling Haaland scored 22 goals with 19 being non-penalty goals, giving him a goal rate of 0.72 per 90 minutes. His shooting accuracy was impressive, contributing to a high goal tally. Alexander Isak netted 23 goals, also with 19 non-penalty goals, resulting in a slightly higher goal rate of 0.75 per 90 minutes. His finishing has been sharp, showcasing his ability to convert chances efficiently. While Haaland has a formidable goal count, Isak edges him out in goal rate and total goals.
Haaland provided 3 assists, contributing to a total of 25 goal involvements (22 goals + 3 assists). Isak had a more significant creative role with 6 assists, totaling 29 goal involvements (23 goals + 6 assists). Isak's ability to create opportunities for teammates makes him the more creative player, contributing 12% of Newcastle's assists compared to Haaland's 6% for City.
Haaland contributed to 31% of Manchester City's goals and 6% of their assists. Isak was crucial for Newcastle, contributing to 35% of their goals and 12% of their assists. Isak's higher contribution percentage signifies his greater importance to Newcastle's attacking play, making him more vital to his team's success despite playing for a less dominant side.
Haaland played 2,736 minutes with a per-90 goal rate of 0.72. Isak logged 2,756 minutes, achieving a per-90 goal rate of 0.75. Isak's slightly higher minutes played alongside a better per-90 goal rate shows superior efficiency. Both players maintained excellent availability throughout the season.
Haaland received 2 yellow cards and no red cards, indicating solid discipline throughout the season. Isak had just 1 yellow card and no red cards, showcasing even better discipline. Isak's cleaner disciplinary record makes him the more reliable option, though both players maintained excellent conduct on the pitch.
Manchester City scored 71 goals in total, while Newcastle scored 66. City's attacking strength is generally higher, giving Haaland more opportunities and better service. However, Isak's contributions were vital in a less prolific team, highlighting his adaptability and importance. Haaland benefits from a stronger supporting cast, but Isak's performance in a less dominant squad is more commendable.
In terms of raw numbers, Isak outperformed Haaland in total goal involvements (29 vs. 25) and had a higher goal contribution percentage. Haaland may have a slight edge in pure goal-scoring reputation, but Isak's overall contributions are more rounded and impactful. Isak's combination of goals and assists, along with efficiency metrics, makes him statistically superior in this head-to-head comparison.
Interested in more player comparisons featuring Erling Haaland? Check out these related matchups:
Want to compare your own player matchups? Use our AI-powered tool to get instant, data-driven analysis of any Premier League players across different seasons.
Compare Players