2024-25 Premier League Season

Mohamed Salah vs Erling Haaland

⚽ Liverpool's Egyptian King vs Manchester City's Norwegian Goal Machine

🤖 AI Evaluation

Mohamed Salah was definitively better than Erling Haaland in the 2024-25 Premier League season, showcasing superior goal contributions, creativity, and defensive work rate.
Mohamed Salah
Liverpool
Age
32
Position
FW
Nationality
EGY
Appearances
38
Key Statistics
29
Goals
18
Assists
47
G+A
0.77
Goals/90
0.48
Assists/90
3,371
Minutes
Defensive Stats
21
Tackles
9
Interceptions
5
Clearances
12
Blocks
47.1%
Tackle Success
30
Def Actions
Team Impact
34.1%
Team Goals
27.7%
Team Assists
1
Yellow Cards
0
Red Cards
Erling Haaland
Manchester City
Age
24
Position
FW
Nationality
NOR
Appearances
31
Key Statistics
22
Goals
3
Assists
25
G+A
0.72
Goals/90
0.10
Assists/90
2,736
Minutes
Defensive Stats
11
Tackles
5
Interceptions
23
Clearances
12
Blocks
37.5%
Tackle Success
16
Def Actions
Team Impact
31.0%
Team Goals
5.9%
Team Assists
2
Yellow Cards
0
Red Cards

📊 The Complete Statistical Breakdown

⚽ Goal Threat & Finishing

Erling Haaland scored 22 goals, with 19 non-penalty goals, showcasing a strong finishing ability. His goals per 90 minutes stands at 0.72. Mohamed Salah netted 29 goals, including 20 non-penalty goals, with a goals per 90 of 0.77. While Haaland's finishing is impressive, Salah's superior total goal count and higher non-penalty goals indicate a slightly better goal threat this season.

🎨 Creative Impact

Haaland provided 3 assists, contributing to a total of 25 goal involvements. Salah excelled with 18 assists, leading to a total of 47 goal involvements. Salah is clearly the more creative player, significantly impacting his team's attacking play.

🛡️ Defensive Contribution

Haaland registered 11 tackles with a success rate of 37.5%, and made 5 interceptions. Salah had 21 tackles with a higher success rate of 47.1%, alongside 9 interceptions. While both players are primarily attackers, Salah's defensive contributions are notably superior, demonstrating a commitment to team defense.

⚡ Team Dependency & Impact

Haaland contributed to 31% of Manchester City's goals and 6% of assists. Salah accounted for 34% of Liverpool's goals and 28% of assists. Salah's contributions are more crucial to his team's overall attacking output, making him a linchpin for Liverpool.

⏱️ Minutes & Efficiency

Haaland played 2,736 minutes across 31 matches, averaging 0.72 goals per 90. Salah logged 3,371 minutes in 38 matches, achieving 0.77 goals per 90 and a remarkable 0.48 assists per 90. Both players are consistent, but Salah's higher minutes and assist rate show his greater efficiency in contributing to the attack.

🟨 Discipline & Reliability

Haaland received 2 yellow cards, while Salah had only 1 yellow card and no red cards. Both players were available for all matches they started. Salah shows slightly better discipline, contributing to his reliability throughout the season.

🏆 Squad Context

Both players operated in elite squads. Manchester City averaged 61.3% possession with 71 goals across the season, while Liverpool maintained 57.7% possession and scored 85 goals. Salah's impact was greater relative to his team's output, contributing to both goals and assists at a higher rate than Haaland did for City.

📈 Overall Statistical Dominance

Haaland's total contributions (goals + assists) stand at 25, while Salah's are at 47. In terms of efficiency metrics, Salah outperformed Haaland in assists, defensive contributions, and overall goal involvement. Salah's dominance in overall contributions and creativity cannot be overlooked.

🔗 More Haaland Comparisons

Interested in more player comparisons featuring Erling Haaland? Check out these related matchups:

⚽ Haaland vs Isak: 2024-25 Season →

Settle the Debate

Want to compare your own player matchups? Use our AI-powered tool to get instant, data-driven analysis of any Premier League players across different seasons.

Compare Players